Decisions
What Happens After a Decision Passes
From passed to carried out
Passing is not the same as happening. Here's what a Decision goes through, and what “carried out” actually means for each kind.
Decision lifecycle
- Draft. Someone's writing it up; not yet visible to the Group for voting.
- Under review. Posted, but voting hasn't opened. Not every Group uses this step; where it is on, the Decision sits for a stated number of days first.
- Active. Voting is open; members cast votes.
- Passed, Did not pass, or Not enough votes. Three outcomes, not two. Reaching the pass share with enough turnout passes. Falling short of the pass share is “Did not pass” — the Group considered it and said no. Running out of time without enough people voting is “Not enough votes”, which is a different thing: nothing was decided, and it can be raised again.
- Carried out. What happens next depends on what the Decision asked for. See below.
A Group can also require a cooling-off period, up to 30 days, between a Decision passing and it becoming carried out. When it's on, a passed Decision shows the date it unlocks, and nothing can act on it until then.
What “carried out” means, by kind
- Spend
- A passed Spend unlocks the treasury approval flow. Approvers still sign before money actually moves. See Who Can Spend, and Who Has to Approve.
- Rule change
- Applies completely or not at all. If any part of it can't be applied (a permission the platform doesn't manage, a member who has since left), nothing changes and the Decision says why.
- Action
- Most Actions are the outcome: the record of agreement is the whole thing. “Move our meeting to Thursdays” happens because people agreed to it, not because software did anything. A short list of group-lifecycle Actions is the exception (pausing the Group, resuming it, or beginning to wind it down), where passing the Decision changes the Group's own state.
Related guides
- Ways Your Group Can Vote: the named processes you choose from.
- How Many Have to Vote, and How Many Have to Agree: quorum, pass share, and per-decision overrides.
Was this page helpful?
Still have questions? Check the FAQ or contact us.